Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Citation
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Parent Document
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Jurisdiction
- United States (federal)
- Effective Date
- 1983-05-12
Other Sections in This Document (51)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
- Williams v. Pierce, 708 F.2d 57 (1983)
Full Text
864 chars34 What appellants do challenge is HUD's "procedure for taking actions"--i.e., its procedure for making rules, which is conspicuously omitted from the unreviewable matters listed in Sec. 322(i)(3) and therefore not precluded from being challenged. This reading of the judicial review provisions cannot be dismissed as "sheer sophistry" (Op. p. 61) but, on the contrary, is called for under Johnson v. Robison, supra; moreover, an insistence on proper procedure and attention to public comments is particularly warranted when an agency has unreviewable substantive discretion. Since HUD has not presented "clear and convincing evidence" that Congress intended to bar review of HUD's refusal to follow proper procedures in formulating rules under Sec. 322, I would find that review is not precluded. See Abbott Laboratories, supra, 387 U.S. at 141, 87 S.Ct. at 1511.