Skip to main content

107 Misc. 2d 470; 435 N.Y.S.2d 449; 1980 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 2877

Citation
107 Misc. 2d 470; 435 N.Y.S.2d 449; 1980 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 2877
Jurisdiction
New York (state)
Source verification
cross_accepted_sealed

Full Text

1,688 chars
The court’s research into the question of impleading third parties into summary proceedings has uncovered decisions involving the New York City Department of Social Services (allowed — see, e.g., Merlin Realty Corp. v Santiago, NYLJ, Oct. 3, 1979, p 14, col 1 [Miller, J.], and Phipps Plaza South Housing Dev. Fund Corp. v Torres, NYLJ, Sept. 26, 1974, p 17, col 7 [Levy, J.]; not allowed — see, e.g., Matter of Estate of Weiss v Downing, NYLJ, Feb. 13, 1975, p 18, col 7 [App Term], and Allison v Medina, NYLJ, July 11, 1974, p 11, col 2 [Shorter, J.]); the United States Veterans Administration (not allowed — Marcy Realty Co. v Glassy, 79 Misc 2d 925 [Nolan, J.]); the New York State Public Service Commission and Consolidated Edison (allowed — Bryant Hoe Corp. v Valentine, 83 Misc 2d 5, 7 [Peck, J.]); a private insurance carrier, after a fire (allowed — Welsh v Lublin, NYLJ, March 28, 1975, p 13, col 8 [Milano, J.]); the Comptroller of the City of New York, President of the City Council and unnamed elected officials, government agencies and community groups (not allowed — 233 233 Co. v City of New York, NYLJ, Sept. 28, 1979, p 5, col 1 [App Term]); a community board established under the city charter (allowed — Housing & Dev. Admin, of City of N. Y. v Ruel Realty Co., NYLJ, Jan. 31, 1979, p 10, col 6 [Cohen, J.]); and even a cotenant of the originally named tenants (72nd Tenants Corp. v Rosen, NYLJ, Dec. 26, 1973, p 16, col 2 [Marks, J.]).

However, no reported case has been found involving the attempted impleader of the New York City Department of Environmental Protection. Accordingly, this is a case of apparent first impression.

*472BACKGROUND TO THE LITIGATION